Below we have provided a complete pin list in chronological order. It is updated by Gpumpkin when a new pin is released.
2006:
Location: Coffee Shop
Music Note Pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Plant Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Pizza Pin
Location: Plaza
Balloon Pin
Location: Dock
Lantern Pin
Location: Night Club
Beach Ball Pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Sun Pin
Location: Book Room
Horseshoe Pin
Location: Mine Shack
Astro Barrier Ship Pin
Location: Snow Forts
Hockey Stick Pin
Location: Ski Village
Soccer Ball Pin
Location: Gift shop
Pencil Pin
Location: Book Room
Light House Pin
Location: Plaza
Telescope Pin
Location: Ski Hill
Pirate Flag Pin
Location: Pet Flag
Pumpkin Pin
Location: Dock
Jet Pack Pin
Location: Beach
Life Ring Pin
Location: Lighthouse
Camp Fire Pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Christmas Tree Pin
Location: Club Penguin Times
Candy Cane Pin
Location: Night Club
2007:
Apple Pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Cactus Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Teddy Bear Pin
Location: Cave
Ice Cube Pin
Location: Iceberg
Shrimp Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Pot of Gold Pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Box Pin
Location: Dock
Microphone Pin
Location: Beacon
Ruby Pin
Location: Ski Village
Tulip Pin
Location: Sport Shop
Starfish Pin
Location: Mine
Surf Board Pin
Location: Beacon
Picnic Basket Pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Water Drop Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Cart Surfer Pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Butterfly Pin
Location: Forest
Tent Pin
Location: Mine Shack
baseball pin
Location: Boiler Room
jelly fish pin
Location: Ski Lodge
circus tent pin
Location: Plaza
paddle ball pin
Location: Snow Forts
Hair brush pin
Location: Pet Shop
spider pin
Location: Cave
UFO pin
Location: Dance Lounge
needle pin
Location: Cove
Holly pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Wreath pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Red snow shovel pinLocation: Pizza Parlor
Cactus Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Teddy Bear Pin
Location: Cave
Ice Cube Pin
Location: Iceberg
Shrimp Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Pot of Gold Pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Box Pin
Location: Dock
Microphone Pin
Location: Beacon
Ruby Pin
Location: Ski Village
Tulip Pin
Location: Sport Shop
Starfish Pin
Location: Mine
Surf Board Pin
Location: Beacon
Picnic Basket Pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Water Drop Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Cart Surfer Pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Butterfly Pin
Location: Forest
Tent Pin
Location: Mine Shack
baseball pin
Location: Boiler Room
jelly fish pin
Location: Ski Lodge
circus tent pin
Location: Plaza
paddle ball pin
Location: Snow Forts
Hair brush pin
Location: Pet Shop
spider pin
Location: Cave
UFO pin
Location: Dance Lounge
needle pin
Location: Cove
Holly pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Wreath pin
Location: Lodge Attic
2008:
Location: Boiler Room
Sombrero pin
Location: Forest
rowboat pin
Location: Lighthouse
Anchor pin
Location: Cove
Golden ship wheel pin
Location: Iceberg
Aqua grabber pin
Location: Cave
Book pin
Location: Boiler Room
Crayon pin
Location: Mine Shack
Pyramid pin
Location: Book Room
Treasure chest pin
Location: Ski Village
Captain's quarters key pin
Location: Book Room
goblet pin
Location: Coffee Shop
anvil pin
Location: Boiler Room
ice cream cone pin
Location: Forest
basketball pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
firework rocket pin
Location: Cove
treble clef pin
Location: Cove
Record pin
Location: Night Club
Dodgeball pin
Location: Stage
150th newspaper pin
Location: Boiler Room
magnifying glass pin
Location: Dock
ruby pin
Location: Stage
lollipop pin
Location: Lighthouse
yellow balloon pin
Location: Forest
microscope pin
Location: Sport Shop
3rd anniversary cake pin
Location: Dance lounge
Blue snow shovel pin
Location: Forest
snowflake tile pin
Location: Beach
snow fort pin
Location: Pet Shop
present pin
Location: Ski Lodge
2009:
gingerbread man pin
Location: Lodge Attic
taco pin
Location: Snow Forts
lily pin
Location: Beacon
Puffle O's pin
Location: Mine
O' berry pin
Location: Iceberg
lucky coin pin
Location: Ski Hill
top hat pin
Location: Lodge Attic
chocolate bunny pin
Location: Forest
tree pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
king's crown pin
Location: Boiler Room
ice cream sundae pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
safari hat pin
Location: Book Room
watermelon pin
Location: Lighthouse
dojo lantern pin
Location: Cave
beach umbrella pin
Location: Boiler Room
toy sailboat pin
Location: Coffee Shop
sand castle pin
Location: Mine
koi fish pin
Location: Cove
cotton candy pin
Location: Forest
101 days pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
fire pin
Location: Scavenger Hunt Prize
padlock pin
Location: Book Room
football pin
Location: Lodge Attic
4th anniversary pin
Location: Boiler Room
castle pin
Location: Dock/Unlock
sled pin
Location: Ski Hill
magic phial pin
Location: Stage
hot chocolate pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Christmas bell pin
Location: Forest
snowman pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Location: Lodge Attic
taco pin
Location: Snow Forts
lily pin
Location: Beacon
Puffle O's pin
Location: Mine
O' berry pin
Location: Iceberg
lucky coin pin
Location: Ski Hill
top hat pin
Location: Lodge Attic
chocolate bunny pin
Location: Forest
tree pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
king's crown pin
Location: Boiler Room
ice cream sundae pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
safari hat pin
Location: Book Room
watermelon pin
Location: Lighthouse
dojo lantern pin
Location: Cave
beach umbrella pin
Location: Boiler Room
toy sailboat pin
Location: Coffee Shop
sand castle pin
Location: Mine
koi fish pin
Location: Cove
cotton candy pin
Location: Forest
101 days pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
fire pin
Location: Scavenger Hunt Prize
padlock pin
Location: Book Room
football pin
Location: Lodge Attic
4th anniversary pin
Location: Boiler Room
castle pin
Location: Dock/Unlock
sled pin
Location: Ski Hill
magic phial pin
Location: Stage
hot chocolate pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Christmas bell pin
Location: Forest
snowman pin
Location: Lodge Attic
2010:
Fireworks pin
Location: Lighthouse
puffer fish pin
Location: Iceberg
amethyst pin
Location: Cave Mine
speaker pin
Location: Pet Shop
feather pin
Location: Beacon
wagon pin
Location: Ski Lodge
buckle boot pin
Location: Dance Lounge
moss key pin
Location: Underwater
cupcake pin
Location: Sport Shop
frog pin
Location: Dock
recycle pin
Location: Scavneger Hunt Prize
leaf pin
Location: Ski Hill
shield pin
Location: Cove
toothbrush pin
Location: Treasure Room
cream soda barrel pin
Location: Book Room
seashell pin
Location: Iceberg
ruby pin
Location: Stage
light bulb pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
candy apple pin
Location: Hidden Lake
tambourine pin
Location: Lodge Attic
compass pin
Location: Boiler Room
carabiner pin
Location: Lighthouse
igloo pin
Location: Cave
popcorn pin
Location: Forest
fair ticket pin
Location: Book Room
sandwich pin
Location: Cave Mine
golden feather pin
Location: Mine Shack
carrot pin
Location: Night Club
bat pin
Location: Cove
water tap pin
Location: Beach
water pin
Location: Iceberg
snowflake pin
Location: Snow Forts
snow globe pin
Location: Dock
ruby brooch pin
Location: Stage
party favors pin
Location: Ski Hill
Location: Lighthouse
puffer fish pin
Location: Iceberg
amethyst pin
Location: Cave Mine
speaker pin
Location: Pet Shop
feather pin
Location: Beacon
wagon pin
Location: Ski Lodge
buckle boot pin
Location: Dance Lounge
moss key pin
Location: Underwater
cupcake pin
Location: Sport Shop
frog pin
Location: Dock
recycle pin
Location: Scavneger Hunt Prize
leaf pin
Location: Ski Hill
shield pin
Location: Cove
toothbrush pin
Location: Treasure Room
cream soda barrel pin
Location: Book Room
seashell pin
Location: Iceberg
ruby pin
Location: Stage
light bulb pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
candy apple pin
Location: Hidden Lake
tambourine pin
Location: Lodge Attic
compass pin
Location: Boiler Room
carabiner pin
Location: Lighthouse
igloo pin
Location: Cave
popcorn pin
Location: Forest
fair ticket pin
Location: Book Room
sandwich pin
Location: Cave Mine
golden feather pin
Location: Mine Shack
carrot pin
Location: Night Club
bat pin
Location: Cove
water tap pin
Location: Beach
water pin
Location: Iceberg
snowflake pin
Location: Snow Forts
snow globe pin
Location: Dock
ruby brooch pin
Location: Stage
party favors pin
Location: Ski Hill
2011:
sleeping bag pin
Location: Coffee Shop
fire extinguisher pin
Location: Dance Lounge
blue puffle pin
Location: Lodge Attic
red puffle pin
Location: Hidden Lake
green puffle pin
Location: Dojo
black puffle pin
Location: Recycling Plant
viking ship pin
Location: Stage
pink puffle pin
Location: Cove
purple puffle pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
white puffle pin
Location: Book Room
yellow puffle pin
Location: Mine Shack
orange puffle pin
Location: Dance Club
brown puffle pin
Location: Ski Village
Quartz pin
Location: Stage
savanna tree pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Medieval shield pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
Mermaid shell pin
Location: Stage
brazier pin
Location: Boiler Room
EPF badge pin
Location: Epf Rooftop
red electric guitar pin
Location: Hidden Lake
stereo pin
Location: Book Room
tiki mask pin
Location: Dock
gold anchor
Location: Iceberg
eye patch pin
Location: Migrator
telescope pin
Location: Iceberg
tropical feather pin
Location: Dock
old key pin
Location: Tree Forts
tropical bird pin
Location: Gift Shop
checkered flag pin
Location: Cove
polar paw print pin
Location: Cave
expedition key pin
Location: Second Laser Maze
AC 3000 pin
Location: Classified Location
balloon bunch pin
Location: Forest
Milkshake pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
purple balloon pin
Location: Forest
snow cone pin
Location: Coffee Shop
fence pin
Location: Beach
crystal ball pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Hot sauce pin
Location: Cave Mine
blue fish pin
Location: Snow Forts
bonsai tree pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Reindeer pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Coins for change 2011 pin
Location: Captain's quarters
candy cane duo pin
Location: Forest
stocking pin
Location: Forest
milk n' cookies pin
Location: Forest
Candy swirl pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Location: Coffee Shop
fire extinguisher pin
Location: Dance Lounge
blue puffle pin
Location: Lodge Attic
red puffle pin
Location: Hidden Lake
green puffle pin
Location: Dojo
black puffle pin
Location: Recycling Plant
viking ship pin
Location: Stage
pink puffle pin
Location: Cove
purple puffle pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
white puffle pin
Location: Book Room
yellow puffle pin
Location: Mine Shack
orange puffle pin
Location: Dance Club
brown puffle pin
Location: Ski Village
Quartz pin
Location: Stage
savanna tree pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Medieval shield pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
Mermaid shell pin
Location: Stage
brazier pin
Location: Boiler Room
EPF badge pin
Location: Epf Rooftop
red electric guitar pin
Location: Hidden Lake
stereo pin
Location: Book Room
tiki mask pin
Location: Dock
gold anchor
Location: Iceberg
eye patch pin
Location: Migrator
telescope pin
Location: Iceberg
tropical feather pin
Location: Dock
old key pin
Location: Tree Forts
tropical bird pin
Location: Gift Shop
checkered flag pin
Location: Cove
polar paw print pin
Location: Cave
expedition key pin
Location: Second Laser Maze
AC 3000 pin
Location: Classified Location
balloon bunch pin
Location: Forest
Milkshake pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
purple balloon pin
Location: Forest
snow cone pin
Location: Coffee Shop
fence pin
Location: Beach
crystal ball pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Hot sauce pin
Location: Cave Mine
blue fish pin
Location: Snow Forts
bonsai tree pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Reindeer pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Coins for change 2011 pin
Location: Captain's quarters
candy cane duo pin
Location: Forest
stocking pin
Location: Forest
milk n' cookies pin
Location: Forest
Candy swirl pin
Location: Coffee Shop
2012:
Conch shell pin
Location: Iceberg
Beach chair pin
Location: Dance Club
Camera pin
Location: Dock
Helm pin
Location: Ski Hill
cheese pin
Location: Bolier Room
cake pin
Location: Book Room
Easter basket pin
Location: Forest
Forest pin
Location: Cave
Round Ruby Pin
Location: Stage
Black Helm Pin
Location: Cove
Scron Crest Pin
Location: Bolier Room
Scron Crown
Location: Mountain of Misery
Bean Bag Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Superhero Pin
Location: Mine Shack
Supervillain Pin
Location: Dojo Courtyard
Dupstep Puffle Pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Sweet Star Pin
Location: Daily Music Challenge
Mega Star Pin
Location: Daily Music Challenge
Super Star Pin
Location: Daily Music Challenge
Gold Star Pin
Location: Daily Music Challenge
Spotlight Pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Banana Peel Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Fruit Combo Pin
Location: Iceberg
Windmill Pin
Location: Dock
Triple Scoop Pin
Location: Ski Lodge
Puffle Bat Key
Location: Beach
7th Anniversary Hat Pin
Location: Cave Mine
Square Ruby
Location: Stage
Gariwald Family Crest Pin
Location: Recycling Plant
Heavy Weights Pin
Location: Boiler Room
Herbert Security Clearance
Location: Herbert's Lair
First Aid Pin
Location: Mine
Snowflake Pin
Location: Cave Mine
Coins For Change Pin 2012
Location: Donation to Coins for Change
Holiday Cookies Pin
Location: Underground Pool
2013:
Dino Footprint Pin
Location: Forest
Stone Hammer Pin
Location: Dock
Shooting Star Pin
Location: Underground Pool
Golden Award Pin
Location: Mountain
Red Nose Comedy Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Rainbow Puffle Pin
Location: Beach
Bunny Rabbit Pin
Location: Dojo
Robot Villain Pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Paper Lantern Pin
Location: Recycling Plant
Elemental Pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Snow Gem Pin
Location: Card-Jitsu Snow Game
Snow Shuriken Pin
Location: Ski Village
Neon Flamingo Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
One Eyed Puffle Pin
Location: Iceberg
Text Book Pin
Location: Dance Club
R2-D2 Pin
Location: Pizza Parlor
Rebel Reward Pin
Location: 'Challenge' game
Calculator Pin
Location: Beacon
Friends Forever Pin
Location: Dance Club
Coconut Smoothie Pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Fluffy Crest Pin
Location: Book Room
Prank Fangs Pin
Location: Cave Mine
Tombstone Pin
Location: Boiler Room
Scissors Pin
Location: Forest
Herbertech Logo Pin
Location: Lighthouse
Puffle Medic Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Ornament Pin
Location: Dance Club
Coins for Change 2013 Pin
Location: Donation to Coins for Change
Penguin Nests Pin
Location: Coins for Change Donation Meter
Clean Water Pin
Location: Coins for Change Donation Meter
Holiday Gift Pin
Location: Boiler Room
2014:
Stone Scissors PinLocation: Forest
Dino Snack Pin
Location: Beach
Pixel Puffle Pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Space Cart Pin
Location: Underground Pool
Pirate Skull Pin
Location: The Daily Spin
Desert Cactus Pin
Location: The Daily Spin
Lion Statue Pin
Location: Mine Shack
Pinata Pin
Location: Coffee Shop
Cream Pie Pin
Location: Mine Shack
Puffle Park Pin
Location: School
Neon O'Berry Pin
Location: Lodge Attic
Picnic Bundle Pin
Location: Lighthouse
Space Academy Crest Pin
Location: Dance Lounge
Orange Slice Pin
Location: Hidden Lake
Penguin Cup 2014 Pin
Location: Shootouts Game Progress
MVP Pin
Location: Gold Mine
Life Preserver Pin
Location: Forest
Cruise Ship Pin
Location: Cove
Arendelle Crest Pin
Location: School
Snowman Puffle
Location: Beacon
Fruit Smoothie
Location: Dock
Lemon
Location: Ski Hill
Scout Scarf
Location: Book Room
Anniversary Balloons
Location: Mine
Ghost
Location: Boiler Room
Wooden Sword
Location: Pizza Parlor
Crab Lock
Location: Coffee Shop
Merry Walrus
Location: Ski Hill
CFC 2014
Location: Limited Edition
Blue Crystal Puffle
Location: Puffle Hotel Lobby
2015:
RebelsLocation: School
Imperial
Location: Clothes Shop
DJ K-Dance
Location: Beach
Pop Star
Location: Not Available
Rockstar
Location: Not Available
Dance
Location: Not Available
Dubstep DJ:
Location: Not Available
Glitterpants
Location: Cove
Puffle Guide Badge
Location: Puffle Lodge (Ski Lodge)
Pi Pie
Location: Book Room
Fishing Rod
Location: Hidden Lake
?????? Footprint
Location: Beacon
Clocktower
Location: Anna's Room
Bracelet
Location: Anna's Room
Flower Bouquet
Location: Anna's Room
Deluxe Sandwich
Location: Anna's Room
Portrait
Location: Anna's Room
Anna and Elsa
Location: Dock
Arendelle Globe
Location: Dock
Old Fishing Rod
Location: Dock
Sparkling Headdress
Location: Dock
Birthday Cake
Location: Dock
Spring Flower
Location: Mine Shack
Pixel Penguin
Location: Dance Club
Issue 500
Location: Book Room
Medieval Monster
Location: Coffee Shop
Beach Day
Location: Puffle Berry Mall
Sunglasses
Location: Plaza
Memory Orb
Location: Cove
